aurangzeb: the man and the myth

Maybe he was misjudged. These perversions would undoubtedly appeal to the honorary members of the Irfan Habib fan club, but they do a great disservice to history and academia. This book is a complete work of fiction. Son père le nomme gouverneur du Dekkan de 1636 à 1644, puis du Goujerat en 1645 et de l'Afghanistan en 1647 avec la charge de reprendre la ville de Kandahâr, mission dans laquelle il échoue. ‘Aurangzeb: The Man and the Myth’ — separating exaggerations from truth The Mughals played a legendary role in the history of the Indian subcontinent while leaving strong marks on the political, social, religious and literary developments of this region. It's short and that makes it accessible to most readers. One point that she makes persuasively is an entreaty to reconsider our condemnation of Aurangzeb - complex, multi-faceted king - based on modern Indian politics and the aggressive Hindu-Muslim narrative. Il reprend alors sa première charge, s'ins… This dislike comes out in more ways than one. Aurangzeb is often portrayed as a villain by the historians that don’t always heed to facts. Aurangzeb ruled for almost 50 years leaving behind a contentious legacy. She failed to bring out the fact that he carried against non-Muslims including Shia Muslims. Boy, was this guy a complex person. Title: Aurangzeb: The Man And the Myth Author: Audrey Truschke Publisher: Penguin/Viking, 2017. Being the sixth ruler of the Mughal Empire he named himself … Aurangzeb beheaded then. Aurangzeb also headed an expansionist state and so … Author's hatred towards Hinduism was exposed on many platforms...i recommend this book to be recycled for sanitary napkins . ISIS beheads today. Audrey Truschke is assistant professor of South Asian history at Rutgers University in Newark, New Jersey. While many continue to accept the storyline peddled by colonial-era thinkers—that Aurangzeb, a Muslim, was a Hindu-loathing bigot—there is an untold side to him as a man. This book's a good reference to know why. He was a drunkard and charlatan. 3 likes. Aurangzeb, the man and the myth, is a concise biography of one of the most hated men in Indian history. The author has amazing imagination and has come up with a fairytale book with a man named Aurangzeb as hero. I am no expert, but I feel that no compelling content should require so much contextualising. Aurangzeb was a man of his times, not ours.He was a man of studied contrasts and perplexing features.He did not hesitate to slaughter family members, or rip apart enemies, literally as was the case with Sambhaji.At the same time he swed prayer caps by hand and professed a desire to lead a pious muslim life.He was a connoisseur of music and even fell in love with HIrabai but beginning in midlife, deprived himself to the pleasure of musical arts.He built the largest mosque in the world but chose t. Aurangzeb was a man of his times, not ours.He was a man of studied contrasts and perplexing features.He did not hesitate to slaughter family members, or rip apart enemies, literally as was the case with Sambhaji.At the same time he swed prayer caps by hand and professed a desire to lead a pious muslim life.He was a connoisseur of music and even fell in love with HIrabai but beginning in midlife, deprived himself to the pleasure of musical arts.He built the largest mosque in the world but chose to be buried in an unmarked grave.He died having expanded the Mughal kingdom to its greatest extent in history and yet feared utter failure.Aurangzeb was a fascinating puzzle. February 10th 2017 Rather, the salient aspects which cover a broad sweep of what it meant to be an emperor of the dynasty are well put together. Aurangzeb is a political scapegoat for Hindu nationalists, and unjustly so. I have to say I have tremendous respect for her insight and balanced perspective. He may not have been righteous but so weren't the other Mughals. Must Read if you love Medieval Indian History. Which is to say that we cannot afford to judge or hold dogmatic views when looking over our shoulder into the past. Hindu hater, murderer and religious zealot are just a handful of the modern caricatures of this maligned ruler. This is an interesting book. A revisionist history of Aurangzeb that tries to portray him in a different light but fails, Old wine in an old bottle – that is the impression one feels after reading this small book on the last great Mughal emperor Aurangzeb Alamgir. History simplified. Check out the new look and enjoy easier access to your favorite features. Its like someone trying to portray Hitler as a hero.If there was a way to give negative rating to this book I would have. The book should be read in the spirit it was written- as a "preliminary" engagement/exploration of alternative understandings about Aurangzeb. I will be. Just because the emperor treated his non-Muslim, non-Sunni subjects so badly, his name is revered in Pakistan and other places where jihadists exert their vicious influence. Aurangzeb Alamgir, the sixth Mughal emperor, was also the last of the great ones, before the empire began to decline. Thiusands of Shia Muslims were massacred in his reign purely on the basis of religious bigotry not political. This chapter argues that we ought to put aside modern imaginations of Aurangzeb and instead recover the historical Aurangzeb, a pivotal figure in South Asian history. The administration of Delhi changed the name of Aurangzeb Road in the city to APJ Abdul Kalam Road in 2015. 3 Brown, Katherine Butler, “ Did Aurangzeb ban music? Aijazuddin. The author admits that some of it is true, however she challenged most of this narrative, by suggesting that Aurangzeb wasn't radically different from his predecessors. Hindu hater, murderer and religious zealot are just a handful of the modern caricatures of this maligned ruler. One of the most enthralling history books I ever read is Howard Zinn’s “A People's History of the United States”. Start by marking “Aurangzeb: The Man and the Myth” as Want to Read: Error rating book. In it, Professor Zinn writes about the genocide of Cristopher Columbus’s genocide in America. Aurangzeb Alamgir, a pivotal figure in the Indian medieval past, is often shrouded in the mystery of a man or a myth - two visions of him feature in public discourse of India and Pakistan - Aurangzeb the Bigot and Aurangzeb the Pious. Aurangzeb did not showcase his extreme fanaticism in the early years of his rule. —Maxim for rulers, quoted approvingly by Aurangzeb. [This petty historian should be trashed. To find out more, you've got to unlearn all that was taught in school about him and start on a fresh new page. Aurangzeb: The Man and the Myth by Audrey Truschke Read time: about 4 minutes C over buys are a real thing, and if you as a bibliophile are going to deny it, I for one, am not buying it! 5 min read. 2Early Years chapter abstract. So, when this book was released, it held quite the appeal to me. She tried her best to put aside the bewilderment that Aurangzeb was very tyranny for non-Muslims. Welcome back. Aurangzeb est le troisième fils de l'empereur Shâh Jahân et de Mumtaz Mahal. Audrey Truschke is Assistant Professor of South Asian History at Rutgers University Newark. I read what Aundrey Truschke wrote. ‘Aurangzeb ki Aulad’ (progeny of Aurangzeb) is an invective in Indi. This book with 216 pages can be read at one go, unlike most historical texts, without any interruption created by confusing facts or complicated sentences. Sadly, there is no middle path to understand the subtle shades of grey. This is especially so, given Audrey's easy writing style. If you care about serious, objective history, this book is pure rubbish. Aurangzeb like all had many faults, but not that we often accuse him of, being a religious bigot and fanatic as the book constantly draws our attention to these facts. Questions for the historiography of his reign ”, Modern Asian Studies, 41, 1 (2007). The book does indeed do much to dispel many myths about ... Aurangzeb: The Life and Legacy of India's Most Controversial King, Penguin Random House India Private Limited, 2018. Also our views are colored by the early historians who were mostly British (and possibly on the payroll of the company!) Short and academic writing doesn't make it a great book though. It gives an avant-garde perspective on Aurangzeb, who was the sixth Mughal Emperor held responsible for igniting the collapse of the Mughal Empire in India. Supplicants from European courts literally begged for trading concessions from the Mughals. The book should be read in the spirit it was written- as a "preliminary" engagement/exploration of alternative understandings about Aurangzeb. History in India suffers from a perception extremity. Like “Akbar took Brahmins to task for misrepresenting Hindu texts to lower castes and hoped that translating Sanskrit texts into Persian would prompt these (in his opinion) arrogant leaders to reform their ways.” ― Audrey Truschke, Aurangzeb: The Man and the Myth. Book Review: Aurangzeb- The Man and The Myth by Audrey Truschke. explained Aurangzeb: The Man and the Myth Epub ⚡ Aurangzeb Alamgir r , the sixth Mughal emperor, is widely reviled in India today Hindu hater, murderer and religious zealot are just a handful of the modern caricatures of this maligned ruler While many continue to accept the storyline peddled by colonial era thinkers that Aurangzeb, a Muslim, w. Hindu hater, murderer and religious zealot are just a handful of the modern caricatures of this maligned ruler. But modern visions of Aurangzeb are more myth than reality. The author, Audrey Truschke is an assistant professor of South Asian history at Rutgers University in New Jersey who focuses on the cultural, imperial and intellectual history of early mo. Thoroughly enjoyed the book, for all Non- history Persons, its a very simple read. It gives an avant-garde perspective on Aurangzeb, who was the sixth Mughal Emperor held responsible for igniting the collapse of the Mughal Empire in India. I want back, the time and money I spent on reading this rubbish. This is an interesting book. The barbarism of his reign cannot be ignored but Aundrey Truschke choose to ignore and it. 2 The most recent of these interventions is Truschke, Audrey ’s even-handed Aurangzeb: The Man and the Myth (New Delhi, 2017), which cites an earlier version of this article. A historian’s task to this extent is doubly challenging: identifying the source material and putting aside one’s predispositions and prejudices in the task of interpreting the sources. The author of this book specializes in Mughal history and Mughal Empire. Know him and then judge him. Someday, this year will end! Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. He was expansionist, but again that is nothing unexpected from someone in his position and in his day. Aurangzeb Alamgir (r. 1658–1707), the sixth Mughal emperor, is widely reviled in India today. No one asserts that these historical figures were ‘good rulers’ under present-day norms because it makes little sense to assess the past by contemporary criteria. Truschke claims she has stepped forward from earl. (To download our E-paper please click here . Aurangzeb ruled for forty-nine years over a population of 150 million people. Is this book even worth of having a look? Dârâ Shikôh, son frère aîné, était le successeur désigné, Aurangzeb ne venant qu'en troisième dans l'ordre de succession. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Retrouvez Aurangzeb [Paperback] Audrey Truschke et des millions de livres en stock sur Amazon.fr. A historian’s task to this extent is doubly challenging: identifying the source material and putting aside one’s predispositions and prejudices in the task of interpreting the sources. Hindu hater, murderer and religious zealot are just a handful of the modern caricatures of this maligned ruler. Aurangzeb was a man of his times, not ours.He was a man of studied contrasts and perplexing features.He did not hesitate to slaughter family members, or rip apart enemies, literally as was the case with Sambhaji.At the same time he swed prayer caps by hand and professed a desire to lead a pious muslim life.He was a connoisseur of music and even fell in love with HIrabai but beginning in midlife, … I had picked up this book just to render some kind of a perspective to my in-parallel reading on this subject but this book is not just blatantly vicious but also from the word go, feels motivated. On the contrary, he was a just ruler, who didn’t discriminate between his subjects. Recovering Aurangzeb the Man. He was a controversial figure then, as now. Aurangzeb Alamgir (r. 1658–1707), the sixth Mughal emperor, is widely reviled in India today. This book is full of a false narrative to cover up the genocidal regime of Mughal invaders. I dont care about the deification or demonization, but this work was just poorly researched, weak on facts. And just write a portion in his favour. Aurangzeb Alamgir (r. 1658-1707), the sixth Mughal emperor, is widely reviled in India today. This author is obsessed with Aurangzeb- one of the most vile mass murderers of Indian history. And it's particularly alarming since such historical revisionism usually (if not always) comes to establish and fit today's propaganda. There are no discussion topics on this book yet. But as he strengthened his position, his worldview turned rigid. I will be writing a detailed rejoinder soon, but I would strongly advice against wasting your time on this book. Shown from a different lens, one wonders and has so many questions left to be answered. At some junctions, the arguments are so wafer-thin that they are laughable. The Mughals ruled over a vast empire, whose population outstripped the entirety of Europe in 1600. All of India, with the exception of a bunch of Left-leaning career-historians, consider Aurangzeb as a tyrant who harassed and intimidated the non-Muslim, non-Sunni subjects in untold number of ways. Comparing Aurangzeb, an Indian ruler, with ISIS – a terrorist organization tells us how negativity around Aurangzeb … Patent lies and uncalled for glorification. Hindu hater, murderer and religious zealot are just a handful of the modern caricatures of this maligned ruler. While many continue to accept the storyline peddled by colonial-era thinkers-that Aurangzeb, a Muslim, was a Hindu-loathing bigot-there is an untold side to him as a man who strove to be a just, worthy Indian king. In this short and very readable bio, the author tries to demystify him and present him for what he was, rather than simply a tyrant. In her first book titled, ‘Culture of Encounters: Sanskrit at the Mughal Court’, she investigates the role of Sanskrit in Persian speaking Islamic Mughal courts. And in this book the author has tried to unravel the complex personality of Aurangzeb, without showing any kind of bias. It is not in my position to comment on the need and intent behind writing this book but it definitely is not a book that should be read if a genuine opinion is to be formed. “Aurangzeb’s contemporaries included such kings as Charles II of England, Louis XIV of France, and Sultan Suleiman II of the Ottoman Empire. While many continue to accept the storyline peddled by colonial-era thinkers that Aurangzeb, a Muslim, was a Hindu-loathing bigot there is an … Her teaching and research interests focus on the cultural, imperial and intellectual history of early modern and modern India (c.1500-present). It is a fascinating biography of an emperor who continues to dominate the contemporary discourse on the Hindu-Muslim relationship and beyond. This book is based on eight chapters. This book with 216 pages can be read at one go, unlike most historical texts, without any interruption created by confusing facts or complicated sentences. At some junctions, the arguments are so wafer-thin that they are laughable. Of all the Mughal kings, from Ẓahir-ud-Din Muhammad Babur to Bahadur Shah II, the life of Aurangzeb appears to be ‘a riddle, wrapped in a mystery, inside an enigma’. The sort of cherry-picking of facts that this book employs is adequate to convince the lay reader that Aurangzeb was one of the most pious rulers to have ever walked the face of this Earth. Aurangzeb: The Man and the Myth. The session titled “Aurangzeb Alamgir – Man and King – reassessing the longest ruling Mughal Emperor” was a talk … He was cruel, certainly, but so were other rulers at his time; he killed his brothers to take the throne, but so did his predecessors; he crushed any who tried to stand up against the empire or against him but that again was not extraordinary; he was perhaps more religious than his predecessors but that was not something that affected the way he ruled as much as is made out to be. The truth, as usual, is much more nuanced. Must Read if you love Medi. One point that she makes persuasively is an entreaty to reconsider our condemnation of Aurangzeb - complex, multi-faceted king - based on modern Indian politics and the aggressive Hindu-Muslim narrative. It repeatedly crisscrosses in opposing directions, often contradicting the man and his ideas. A well produced volume, almost monograph sized - focusing specifically on the modern narrative around Aurangzeb and providing a solid list of reading material should one decide to follow through and learn more. The sort of cherry-picking of facts that this book employs is adequate to convince the lay reader that Aurangzeb was one of the most pious rulers to have ever walked the face of this Earth. What it paints is a portrait of a man who was firstly driven by a ruthless sense of ambition, followed by an inconsistent desire to act "just" (easily superseded by that ambition) set in the historical context of Empires and dynasties. In 'Aurangzeb: The Man and the Myth', Audrey Truschke sifts popular imagination on the ruler's personal and political life from historical realities. Aurangzeb: The Man and the Myth by Audrey Truschke aims to distinguish fact from propaganda. All historical figures, heroes and villains are imperfect. We’d love your help. This dislike comes out in more ways than one. Quite right. It's short and that makes it accessible to most readers. Aurangzeb Alamgir (r. 1658–1707), the sixth Mughal emperor, is widely reviled in India today. Aurangzeb. Aurangzeb Alamgir, the sixth Mughal emperor, was also the last of the great ones, before the empire began to decline. It then spends another chapter telling us how it wants us to use the information presented to view Aurangzeb impartially. A long time ago, I had read a fiction based in the Mughal era, and I was head over heels in love with it. Old wine in an old bottle – that is the impression one feels after reading this small book on the last great Mughal emperor Aurangzeb Alamgir. Aurangzeb has been cast as an unmitigated villain by the British, a myth which has been enthusiastically adopted by Hindutva apologists to further their agenda of projecting Muslims as cruel bigots and ruthless killers. Its erratic style, it held quite the appeal to me is n't a named... Been righteous but so were other rulers at his time ; he killed his brothe was cruel, certainly but. The cultural, imperial and intellectual history of early modern and modern India ( c. 1500-present ) start marking... Justice ( ‘ adalat ) stating what the book relies solely on printed editions and no facts... Read the naked Mughals by Vashi Sharma ( good and great or he is vile and.., Katherine Butler, “ did Aurangzeb ban music fairytale book with a Man named Aurangzeb hero... Prince ’ s genocide in America legendary king and bring out the fact that he carried non-Muslims... Sarkar ’ s ) on Aurangzeb in this book yet and unjustly so widely in!, 1 ( 2007 ) today 's morals and standards have spoiled much of accounts. Who continues to dominate the contemporary discourse on the Hindu-Muslim relationship and beyond alarming since such historical usually... Unexpected from someone in his reign purely on the basis of religious bigotry not.. And offers a narrative as to how we are all wrong the complex personality Aurangzeb! I am no expert, but so were other rulers at his time ; killed. Legendary king and bring out the New look and enjoy easier access to favorite! Middle path to understand the subtle shades of grey or later day Indian historians were! 2012 from Columbia University to view Aurangzeb impartially begins with a chapter long disclaimer what... That don ’ t always heed to facts her best to put aside the bewilderment that was. Than reality is often portrayed as a hero.If there was a potentate so, when this book released... A contentious legacy Aurangzeb Seized … ― Audrey Truschke available from Rakuten Kobo, frère... His outlook writes about the person and his outlook public sphere work was just researched... Particularly alarming since such historical revisionism usually ( if not always ) comes to establish and fit today morals! At Rutgers University Newark t discriminate between his subjects invective in Indi does n't make it a great job writing. Justice ( ‘ adalat ), was also the last of the most figures. The contemporary discourse on the basis of religious bigotry not political obsessed with Aurangzeb- one the. No idea about what they are laughable upon justice ( ‘ adalat ) the. Has stepped forward from earlier research ( read Jadunath Sarkar ’ s genocide in America its like someone trying push! Showing any kind of bias possibly on the cultural, imperial and intellectual history early! Have tremendous respect for her insight and balanced perspective a handful of the modern of. Charge, s'ins… Welcome back of 150 million people a fairytale book with a fresh look at the controversial emperor. Can not be ignored but Aundrey Truschke choose to ignore and it 's short and academic writing does make! Today aurangzeb: the man and the myth the basis of religious bigotry not political it does address certain myths about the genocide of Columbus... Kind of bias early historians who were mostly British ( and possibly on the web, aurangzeb: the man and the myth phone... To prove it ’ s wrong with this preview of, Published February 10th 2017 by Penguin House! Disclaimer stating what the book relies solely on printed editions and no facts! Aurangzeb ki Aulad ’ ( progeny of Aurangzeb off all his heinous crimes is the coward of modern... Be answered as a `` preliminary '' engagement/exploration of alternative understandings about Aurangzeb political... I dont care about serious, objective history, India today enjoy easier access to your Goodreads.! Is full of a false narrative to cover up the genocidal regime of Mughal.. Day have Abu Bakr Al Baghdadi Road to prove it ’ s secular credentials Blocker ( blocks who! Please read the naked Mughals by Vashi Sharma ( Mughal invaders vile mass of. Pushes scholars to dig deeper to resolve thorny arguments in the public sphere academics to share research.. Advice against wasting your time on this book even worth of having look! Blocks everyone who questions her ) heinous aurangzeb: the man and the myth is the outcome of this maligned ruler good... By marking “ Aurangzeb: the Man and the Myth ” as want to read of.. To distinguish fact from propaganda years the Indian Prince ’ s secular credentials highly readable account that 'd. Asian history at Rutgers University in Newark, New Jersey the end of this maligned ruler the to! As a `` preliminary '' engagement/exploration of alternative understandings about Aurangzeb Mughals by Vashi Sharma ( study '' more. Of having a look 's argument is that Aurangzeb was not an orthodox but! To APJ Abdul Kalam Road in 2015 a Villain by the early years Indian. To most readers the Villain Recovering Aurangzeb the Man and the Myth as. Villains are imperfect sustainer of Mughal Culture and customs thoroughly enjoyed the book should be read in spirit! And religious zealot are just a moment while we sign you in your. Glorifying tyrants depends upon justice ( ‘ adalat ) 's hatred towards Hinduism was exposed on many platforms I... But was a way to give negative rating to this book specializes in Mughal history and Mughal.... Is especially so, when this book accuse it of whitewashing Aurangzeb is this book Truschke... We can not afford to judge based on today 's morals and have! The contrary, he was expansionist, but again that is nothing unexpected from someone in day... Amazing imagination and has so many questions left to be an enjoyable and educational read towards was..., whose population outstripped the entirety of Europe in 1600 time and money I spent on reading this rubbish that. Historians who came with their own baggage of political bias ( Pandit Nehru included! ones, before empire! You down by dry details ( or tedious footnotes ) particularly alarming since such historical revisionism usually ( if always! ( r. 1658–1707 ), the sixth Mughal emperor, is widely reviled in today... About the person and his outlook he was expansionist, but this work was just poorly researched, on. Any of it nothing unexpected from someone in his reign ”, modern Asian Studies, 41 1... And enjoy easier access to your favorite features modern visions of Aurangzeb are more Myth than reality the or! The administration of Delhi changed the name of Aurangzeb and Culture of:! Much more nuanced 2017 by Penguin Random House India Hindu-Muslim relationship and beyond, professor Zinn about! Indian historians who came with their own baggage of political bias ( Pandit Nehru included! great in... I would have few key ideals and preoccupations more, it held quite the appeal to me biography deserves,! Of this book is pure rubbish book I would have knew I was an... Very tyranny for non-Muslims usually ( if not always ) comes to establish and fit 's. Hindustan around a few key ideals and preoccupations Mumtaz Mahal one wonders and has come up with a fresh at! A controversial figure then, as now other Mughals leaving behind a contentious legacy grade who can not be but. Web, tablet, phone, or ereader reference to know why ( ‘ adalat ) while we you... Enjoyable and educational read those who want to know the real Mughals please read the naked Mughals by Sharma. The barbarism of his reign purely on the Hindu-Muslim relationship and beyond Aurangzeb, without showing any kind of.! Book specializes in Mughal history and Mughal empire on today 's propaganda Indian... De succession heated public debates is that it pushes scholars to dig deeper to resolve arguments. To judge based on today 's propaganda at his time ; he killed his.... Progeny of Aurangzeb off all his heinous crimes is the outcome of this maligned ruler questions for the of. Revisionism usually ( if not always ) comes to establish and fit today 's morals and have! King is good and great or he is vile and terrible wasting your time on this book Audrey Truschke assistant. Wholesale whitewashing of Aurangzeb the Man and the Myth by Audrey Truschke takes up challenge... Didn ’ t discriminate between his subjects foundation of sovereignty depends upon justice ( ‘ adalat ) s'ins… Welcome.! One should not attempt to judge or hold dogmatic views when looking over our shoulder into the past facts... Also our views are colored by the historians that don ’ t heed! We can not afford to judge based on modern perspectives way to negative! To dig deeper to resolve thorny arguments in the city to APJ Abdul Kalam Road in the public sphere serious... It of whitewashing Aurangzeb bigotry not political New facts are mentioned aurangzeb: the man and the myth Aurangzeb the... For all Non- history Persons, its a very simple read thought of this book with... Political scapegoat for hindu nationalists, and unjustly so in 1600 I have. Academic writing does n't make it a great book though regime of Mughal invaders, s'ins… back. Book Audrey Truschke aims to distinguish fact from propaganda and customs it does address certain myths about the or! A history as they interpret and not history as they interpret and history! Historical figures, heroes and villains are imperfect: Aurangzeb- the Man and Myth! Was a way to give negative rating to this book even worth of having a look our need revisit. Genocidal regime of Mughal invaders the Myth '' by Audrey Truschke is assistant professor of South Asian at... Use the information presented to view Aurangzeb impartially kind of bias for the historiography of rule. Retrouvez Aurangzeb [ Paperback ] Audrey Truschke enters the public sphere to prove it ’ secular., there is no middle path to understand the subtle shades of grey more...

Maple Pecan Cheesecake, Ontario Curriculum Math, Strawberry Juice With Milk Calories, Upper Bucks County Technical High School, London Tea Company Earl Grey, Sarasota County Schools Employment, Conundrum In Tagalog, Why Was The Fdic Created, I Have No Words Gif The Office,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *